Corrections · 2
赞成!谢谢你的文章,很有意思,特别是方唐镜的那个故事。我估计我们所有外国人都曾经犯过你说的那些错误。标点符号的确很重要。 如果你不介意,我就有一个小小的评论。我觉得你这个句子有点儿逻辑不通。你仔细地看一下吧。如果我误解了那么你能不能给我解释一下它的结构和语法?
"要知道,汉语的标点符号,是很严格使用的,多一个标点符号和少一个标点符号,又或者不同的标点符号,都有改变篇章大意的力量,甚至是很关键的。"
还有,我已把你这篇文章翻译成英文,希望更多的人可以享受。我没有直译,但是大体上这个翻译应该很接近你写的。
Hey guys! As a Chinese person, I am happy to see that there are so many foreigners here studying Mandarin. Since you are all so hard working, I thought I would offer some advice. Let me just get straight to it. I find there are often some recurring problems with the entries that you are uploading here. Please let me point them out to you.
First, a lot of you make a habit out of excessive repetition, or maybe I can say that this happens because you do not know entirely how to say what you are trying to say. Let me give you an example. “Today my mother and I went window shopping, at lunch my mother and I went to McDonalds and bought french fries.” There are a lot sentences like these. The first half of the sentence has already explained what people are involved, so there is no need to repeat that information in the second half. It can be omitted. Another problem is the use of pronouns. When you have already pointed out the subject(s) in the first clause, then you can use pronouns to refer back to them in the second. When talking about people with long names, it is especially important to simplify stuff. You should try not to be too repetitious and wordy in Chinese.
Second, the use of punctuation. Sometimes with long sentences, it is important to take pauses in some places. Keep in mind that in Chinese, punctuation is very strict. Having one punctuation mark too many, one too few or using the wrong one, which will affect the overall meaning/flow of what you are writing. Correct punctuation is essential. Those of who you have seen Zhou Xing Chi’s movie, “Hail the Judge” should be familiar with the scene in which the lawyer Fang Tang Jing’s mischievous use of pauses in reading led to the emperor family’s deeds being returned back to the domain of use/validity, unexpectedly making the emperor indebted. In Classical Chinese, there were no punctuation marks, but everybody got it, the sentences could be read and the text could be understood. But Fang Tang Jing’s use of pauses changed the meaning of the text as he read it, thereby turning it into evidence against the imperial family, even though they had done nothing wrong. No matter if, you are talking about the past or the present, just as you must take pauses when reading in classical Chinese, you also have to use correct punctuation in modern vernacular Chinese. In many of the articles I have read on italki, the punctuation use is pretty good, and then there are some novice students that have not quite gotten it yet. I sometimes explain this in my corrections.
Actually, my friends, if you just understand how to use punctuation, your writing will be much more interesting. In Chinese, every punctuation mark has its own usage, and I would urge you to try to understand each one a little better. Even if we are sometimes perfectly capable of understanding your meaning, sometimes it can also be so confusing that we are not able to grasp what you are trying to say, much less correct your entry.
Disclaimer: I get the gist of that first sentence about Fang Tang Jing, but some of the details eludes me. Perhaps someone else can explain it better.
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
