Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagTakuya
English grammar
I read a textbook about English grammar.
The book said the following examples.

① × Seeing is to belive.
✔︎To see is to believe.
② × The aim of the paper is stating.
✔︎The aim of the paper is to state.
③ × The techniques of ballet are designed displaying the human body.
✔︎The techniques of ballet are designed to display the human body.

Unfortunately, the reasons are not written on the book. I'm looking for someone to teach me the reasons.

I'm very glad if you teach me.

Comments · 3

2
For numbers 2 and 3, the meaning of “to” is “in order to”, so we cannot replace the infinitive with the gerund.

For number 1, I don’t like your book. Although it is correct either way, the fixed expression that we use all the time is “seeing is believing”. More generally, in today’s English we usually use the gerund before the copula, and the infinitive after:
“Playing is fun” or “It’s fun to play”. So, according to this logic, we could theoretically say “seeing is to believe”. The problem is that it seems weird to use two different forms of the verb when they appear to be in parallel. By that criterion, “to see is to believe” would work better, and in fact, we do use that form in the phrase “to know them is to love them”. But as I said, “seeing is believing” is a set phrase, so it should be used verbatim, regardless of grammar or current stylistic trends.

Was your book written by a native English speaker?
2
Honestly both answers for each question would be fine, although the answers it gives as correct sound more fluid and are used more often.

As an explanation, in English the infinitive form of the verb is made by adding "to" in front, as in:
-to see
-to state
-to display
The infinitive is most often used with other verbs:
-I want to see.
-I would like to state.
-I need to display.
But the infinitive can also be used as a noun, like in the examples your book gave.
When a verb is used like this as a noun, it can also be used with the "-ing" form. This second form is probably more colloquial or informal. The "to" forms are more formal.

In example 1, "To see is to believe" sounds pretty formal. Notice how there are two infinitives being used as a noun. Think of the sentence as "Noun is Noun". BUT you could also say "Seeing is believing." This is more common and more informal. The first sentence your book gives, "Seeing is to believe", isn't necessarily wrong, but sounds clunky because it uses both of the different forms.

Also, when you use the "to" form, this can be used to mean "in order to". For example 3, it could be written, "The techniques of ballet are designed in order to display the human body." The other sentence is just saying that the design involves "displaying the human body", but isn't necessarily for that purpose.

In example 2, the word "aim" has a similar meaning to in order to or for, so the "to state" sounds better. The sentence could be, for example, "The paper is written in order to state."

Hopefully this made sense and wasn't too confusing. Don't worry too much if you don't understand it all, like I said, none of those examples are completely wrong, some are just better used in certain places.
0
Mr. Phil and Mr.Jack
Thank you so much for your help. I really appreciate it.

My book was written by Japanese.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today