Search from various English teachers...
Poland flagPaulina
Past Simple and Past Continuous. I'm so confused...

I've got these two sentences…

1) We watched some amazing sunsets while we were staying in Scotland

2) My brother sat in the kitchen when I was getting home

According to my friend's teacher they are correct. 


Why can't I just say:


1) We were watching some amazing sunsets while we were staying in Scotland

2) My brother was sitting in the kitchen when I got home.


I'm so confused. I thought that Past Continuous refers longer actions that was in progres and "sitting" and "watching are ones.

And why "I was getting home"? I thought that it was sort of short action….


Please someone help me

Comments · 2

1

Paulina,
I frequently work with natives of Slavic languages learning English and can tell you you are not alone :) I have also learned a few Slavic languages and it has taken me years to adapt to using the "perfect vs imperfect verbal aspects" of Slavic languages. Reading some text book rules is not enough. You will need a lot of time to observe the natural use of the language to get the "feel". Here are my observations:

1. If the holiday/vacation/stay in Scotland is now 100% finished and in the past, I think "we watched" amazing sunsets would be more accurate.  The 2nd part depends on the speaker.. just a choice. Choosing the word "while", would be used if you want to emphasize the timing was (in the process of visiting) "while we were visiting" Scotland. However, you can also say.. We watched amazing sunsets "when" we visited Scotland. In this 2nd example, you are not trying to emphasize it was "during" the visit/stay/trip in Scotland.

2. Your alternative phrase: My brother was sitting in the kitchen when I got home. Is 100% OK. It gives the idea your brother was "hanging out" in the kitchen when you got home. There is nothing special to describe about your "getting home" so it makes more sense to use the simple "got home".

My general advice would be to take a more relaxed approach to this. Instead of reading text book rules/descriptions of simple vs progressive and worrying about it when you write or speak, I would try to read, watch, listen to content you enjoy and pay attention to the uses of tenses in the context of the stories. This is much more enjoyable and will show you how natives use the language.

I hope this helps a little. You are doing a terrific job to have arrived to this point of trying to refine your skills with the language. Keep up the good work, and "Keep your chin up" (don't get discouraged), you're doing great!


1

Hi Paulina, I'll try to explain the sentences. You're partly correct.

We watched some amazing sunsets while we were staying in Scotland.

This is a perfectly correct sentence. "While we were staying..." provides the context, and you can use past simple ("we watched...") to show regular, completed actions in that time.  The actions in your version don't fit together, time-wise.


However, I agree your version of the second sentence is correct:

My brother was sitting in the kitchen when I got home.

The past continuous provides a context for past simple.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today