IMHO, a trained professional teacher will do an informal assessment (ongoing assessment, actually) and then devise a path that suits the level, goals, needs and preferences of the learner. Ideally...
Do you go to a restaurant and tell the chef how to make the salad? :)
You tell the chef what you want but you leave the method up to her, yes?
I'm curious what it is about Total Physical Response with stories that interests you? Are you looking for lessons for a Young Learner? That would be my first question -- what is the AIM / GOAL for which you've settled on TPR as your method?
Some considerations:
How should the teacher CONVEY the meaning of the story (first), since comprehension usually precedes any kind of response from a learner? How long is the story? Sometimes student choose materials that aren't amenable to a single lesson. Will it presented as a text (and what percentage of the words are at each level -- will any (what precentage) need to be pre-taught? How much tolerance does the individual learner have for presentation activities that generally teacher-centred, learner-passive?
OR Will it be presented as an audio? Does the student want to focus on listening (gist listening for the idea or to hear specific words / answer a list of progressively more difficult questions) OR Is it about vocabulary (Do you want to hear explanations / meanings? What persentage of the vocabulary is known to the learner and what percentage would be new? Do you want to make example sentences? Is the point for the learner to practice hearing and responding to known vocabulary (consolidation) or is about speaking and using the vocabulary?
etc etc