Search from various English teachers...
China flagNicolaus. V. Wang
why do so many people think cantonese and mandarin have nothing in common?

I've seen so many non-Chinese people say something like,"a mandarin-speaking person can never ever understand Cantonese unless they learn it"..wow, I don't really think so, I'm a mandarin speaker and I can understand part of Cantonese but I haven't learned it and I live in central China.

Comments · 9

1

So, let's say that one speaker only knows Mandarin and the other only Cantonese, will they be able to converse with each other regardless of shared writing system? If not, then it means they speak different language.

0

some brazilian think that chineses, japaneses, coreans , vietmaneses, indonesian, malayans ,....are alike. They are the same. lolol 

0

let's give you a few examples..

1. norwegian, swedish and danish are mutually intelligible to a large extent but they are three "different" languages.

2. German is composed of high german and low german, dutch is one of low german dialects, so standard German and Dutch are both German dialects but they don't have high intelligibility.

3. Lao and Thai are similar to each other and they can understand their languages to a large extent but they are called languages, not dialects.

4. so sometimes whether a language is a language only partially depends on linguistics, but largely depends on political decision.

0

they can but not 100% intelligible

0

Cantonese is just dialect. i say this just as a chinese.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today