Torsten gets it 90% right, but it should be "du bist über allem". über+Dativ.
Wait, doesn't it say "Deutschland über alles" in the 1st stanza of Das Lied der Deutschen? Correct... I've thought about it. That line in Deutschlandlied is a half-phrase, sth is left out.
If über were used in terms of position, it should be: Deutschland (ist, steht) über allem. Dativ.
But apparently it is not. This is an direction kind of über. Deutschland (erhebe sich) über alles, for example. Akkusativ.
That makes a lot of sense, given the context of the song (1848 revolution). We are still in the era of Deutscher Dualismus, Habsburg vs. Hohenzollern / Prussia vs. Austria, and some small rubble in between such as the Königreich (Kingdom) of Bavaria and Großherzogtum (grand duchy) of Baden. Germany, the German nation, clearly did not stand above anything, such as particular interests of feudal rulers with privileges from fifteenhundredwhatnot. Then there's the Schutz und Trutz bit about standing united against alien threats, I think that has to do with Napoleon and the Franzosenzeit (time of French occupation). Okay but that really leads us off the grammatical topic, I will cut off the rambling :)