I meant to wait till the kids [ "were "or "have been '] in bed to tell you. which is right?
Were or have been fits there? And why? Thank you very much.but she tell the story now.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
2
Hi 辉
'have been in bed' would indicate that they were in bed at one time, but are not in bed now.
I don't know how to explain the precise grammar, but I hope this is helpful:
You can use:
I meant to wait till the kids were in bed to tell you. - continuous past action of 'to be in bed'. They reached the 'constant' state of being in bed, without indicating anything about whether or not they are still there.
I meant to wait till the kids had gone to bed to tell you. - single action, 'to go to bed', completed in the past. There are rather a lot of 'to's in the sentence, so I would probably use the first one instead!
1
I meant to wait till the kids "were" in bed to tell you is the right statement. "have been" is more like a helping verb. Like I "have been" to France once before. Have been is most likely to be used in the past, for example, I have been to Germany 2 years ago. Were is most likely to be used for things that happened in the past hour or days or weeks. For example, You were at the store 2 hours ago, what can you possibly forget? or You were spending the night at Sally's house yesterday, weren't you?
In other words
"I meant to wait till the kids 'were' in bed to tell you."- indicates the listenter that you have something urgent to tell him and you don't want the kids around.
I meant the wait till the kids 'have been' in bed to tell you."- indicates the listener that you had something urgent to tell him but it seemed to have slipped your mind.
0
@Neal,
I always try to follow the KISS rule. [Keep It Simple, Stupid!]. The rule isn't meant to be derogatory, just a reminder to simplify things before trying to figure them out.
You are right about the sentence, Neal, and my last post wasn't a contradiction. I was trying to explain "why" because 辉 asked for the correct answer and the reasoning for the correct answer.
0
@choppy. You seem to be examining the second verb in isolation. How can you re-write a sentence by leaving out the first half of it, ignoring the first verb? My original point was that the particular combination of tenses in "I meant to wait till the kids have been in bed" did not seem viable. My understanding is that this is a past perfect simple verb, qualified by a present perfect continuous verb in the same sentence, and I can't think of any examples of where this would work.
I will not comment further to this thread; I'm in danger of digging a very deep hole for myself!
0
Likewise Neal, I am not a grammar expert either, but I do know what sounds right, and on that point we agree.
To show some examples without an indefinite article ("a/an"):
1) These examples have been good for me, I have learned a lot from them. (I'm still benefiting from them)
2) These examples were good for me. (I learned from them, and I am better from having learned, but now I can move on to other, more difficult examples).
The problem with 辉's example is that it is sometimes ok to use "have been". If we say something simple, like, "the kids have been in bed (for 2 hours)", it is correct. The kids went to sleep in the past and are still sleeping.
Also, if we use the simple statement, "the kids were in bed", then this, by itself, tends to make us think that the kids are awake now, or could be awake now (possibly not in bed at the present time).
But this sentence has the word, "until". The word "until" brings us to a particular point in time.
I meant to wait till [a time when] the kids were in bed to tell you.
We can re-write the sentence and simplify it. In these examples, I'll leave out the literal word "until", but I will keep the reference to a point in time.
1) The kids were in bed at that time.
2) The kids were in bed at 8 o'clock.
3) The kids were in bed when the sun went down.
Now let's try the simplified sentence with "have been", and we see the main difference.
1) The kids have been in bed for 3 hours / The kids have been in bed since that time.
2) The kids have been in bed since 8 o'clock.
2) The kids have been in bed since the sun went down.
The kids were in bed at a point in time, and they have been in bed for a duration of time.
The difference is ...
Point in time / vs / duration of time.
when, at, until, before, after / vs / since, for
Again, the tricky part is that the original sentence implies a point in time, but doesn't literally express it ("until [a point in time when] ....").
Hope that helps!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
