Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagMaria S
Use of article Hey, could you help me, please? If I want to say: " To be healthy, one should work out and eat healthy. Just eating healthy food is not ___ key." Which article should I use before " key"?

Answers · 15

1
You need 'the'; just eating healthy food is not the key. In this case the key that you're talking about, while not literal, is specific. It is the key / solution to the problem. It is the specific solution to the problem you've outlined. Or in this case, specifically not the solution to the problem you've outlined. I also don't think the sentence reads very well, to me. It's not wrong, but strange. In this case I'd say: - Eating healthy food is only part of the solution. You could also change the whole thing around and go for: The key to being healthy is exercise and eating well. You can't only/just eat healthy food. I feel like, although I'm not sure, that you don't see 'key' used in the negative very often. It sounds a little jarring to me. It is usually a positive. "The key to being healthy" Rather than "Is not the key" (in this case I'd use solution/answer).
1
Your colleague is wrong, Maria: the only possible article is 'the'. The word 'key' is being used figuratively here, and noun phrase 'the key' - a singular noun with the definite article - is needed when it means 'the [one and only] solution' or 'the [one and only] answer'. We only use the indefinite article with 'key' (or 'keys' in the plural) if we are talking about a literal key to open a door or the 'answer' to a question in a test in a grammar or vocabulary exercise, for example. Two other language points about your sentence: -It is slightly odd to use 'the key' at end of the sentence, especially in the negative. It is more usual to say, for example, "the key to being healthy is working out and eating well". - 'Eat healthy' is not correct in standard English, although you might hear it in some places. While there are some words which function as both adjectives and adverbs ( "hold tight", for example), 'healthy' is not one of these. To be grammatically correct, you should either say 'eat healthy food', as some people have suggested, or use an adverb and say 'eat healthily'. I hope that helps.
1
Just eating healthy food is not the key. You should use the definite article because the meaning of the sentence requires to be specific: the key, like the solution to that problem, cannot be only eating healthy ;)
1
You would say 'Just wating healthy food is not the key'.
0
Thank you, Ben! Healthy and healthily has been a really hot topic among examiners here recently:) Students have a lot of language input from online sources, where " to eat healthy" is gaining acceptance, as you mentioned, but the essays are still assessed by academic standards.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today