Search from various English teachers...
China flagOotred 春 🍒🍒🍒🍒🍒
How do I grammatically analyze this sentence? "If you are attacked, heaven forbid it actually happening, and do not survive, then you did not survive." - Nanren888- 新西兰 Source: https://www.italki.com/question/506559 What type of sentence is this? How many clauses does this sentence have? Why are there four punctuation marks in this sentence? Thanks for your help.

Answers · 3

0
Jeremy and Jesse, thanks for your information showing such crystal clear clarity. Now it is my turn. I command my mind to make two sentences using this style of sentence structure: "If a beast is inside you - heaven forbid it actually happening - and tempt you, then you must overcome yourself." "If you see something you shouldn't see, heaven forbid it actually happening, and can't forget it, then you must forgive yourself seeing it."
0
Maybe this helps: "If you do not survive, then you did not survive." Complex sentence of a dependent (if you) and independent (then you) clause. In such a sentence, you always separate the two clauses with a comma. "If you are attacked and do not survive, then you did not survive." (same deal here, the first clause is still dependent, but a little longer) "Heaven forbid it actually happening that you are attacked" (this is an independent clause) "If you are attacked, heaven forbid it actually happening, and do not survive, then you did not survive." (now, "heaven forbid it actually happening" modifies the first statement. With clauses that offer supplementary information, you typically separate it from the rest of the text with two commas.
0
This is a completely ordinary complex sentence, composed of a dependent clause "if you" and an indepedent clause, "then you." What's confusing you is the adverbs. Remember that adverbs have four jobs in English: modifying verbs, adjectives, other adverbs, and entire clauses. Also, adverbs don't have to be one word. Armed with this knowledge, can you see that "heaven forbid it actually happening" is simply an averb modifying the dependent clause "if you are attacked". In fact, a lot of modern writers would set that part off from the rest of the sentence with dashes instead of commas for added clarity. Moving on, the independent clause, "then you did not survive" is really "you did not survive" modified by an adverb doing the same type of job: modifying an entire clause. It's not a subordinating adverb, by the way. It's actually a very simple sentence once you understand what the adverbs are doing.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today