Search from various English teachers...
Emory
[ Grammar ] Absolute phrase S1: Mark has three daughters, all of whom like classical music. S2: Mark has three daughters, and all of them like classical music. S3: Mark has three daughters, all of them liking classical music. ---- I know S1, S2, and S3 are grammatically correct. However, I was wondering that why S3 seems to be unnatural to native speakers? Thanks a lot : )

Answers · 20

1
The construction in S3 is used only in a very specific context, one that implies "because". Dave being a great fan of Ed Sheeran, I got an autograph after the concert and gave it to him later. (i.e. I got him an autograph *because* he is a fan of Ed Sheeran) The farmer has switched his crop this year, maize bringing in a greater profit than last year. (i.e. the farmer has switched *because* of the greater profit) Your example implies that Mark has three daughters *because* they all like classical music - which is clearly absurd.
1
In S3 "liking" sounds wrong. This would be OK; S4: Mark has three daughters, he finds that all of them are liking classical music as they mature.
1
You can't use LIKING in the third sentence because you need a verb in that position.  Think about the basic grammar of English: Subject + VERB.  You need a verb after the word THEY. LIKING is the present participle (the -ing form) of LIKE.  Usually, present participles/the -ing forms are used as verbs but not always. They can also function as nouns. LIKING CLASSICAL MUSIC is actually a NOUN phrase. LIKING CLASSICAL MUSIC is a marker of good taste. A liking for classical music is a marker of good taste.
0
Dear Jaclyn, I googled it, and I just find a few examples. It's a tricky question. ^_^ Anyway, thank you : )
0
I don't know... it just sounds weird and no one says that...

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today