Search from various English teachers...
China flagRebecca 静芳 รีเบคก้า
Русские вопросы In Возьмите со стола тарелки, пожалуйста, what is the case for со стола? Is it the Instrumental case or Accusative case here?

Answers · 7

0
Со стола is the Genitive. If you are familiar with the Prepositional case, then you know that they something that is НА столе ( on the surfice of the table) / НА работе -at an activity/ is used with preposition НА . That is when you want to specify location. Movement from that place is the Genitive, and preposition НА turns into С ---- с работы / со стола / с урока When in Prepositional you have preposition В , it turns into ИЗ ------ в столе -из стола/ в офисе - из офиса / в школе - из школы
0
Спасибо Ceci! I agree with you!
0
Hi Rebecca, I disagree with Bekzat, This is GENITIVE. C/co is the preposition meaning "from" that requires родительный падеж (genitive case). The accusative here is "тарелки". This sentence means "Take the plates from the table, please". WHAT should I take? The тарелки (plates)- here is your ACCUSATIVE. And in accusative remember that if it's an inanimated object you won't write столA. This will be when you talk about a living creature. As for INSTRUMENTAL, you are not using the table or the plates to do anything, and "C" is not the preposition "with" that is followed by INSTRUMENTAL. You can see this immediately because "стола" is not instrumental, "столoм" would be. In Russian there is "C(o)": with + INST and "C(o)": from (also "down") + GEN. There is also "c" meaning "approximately" and it will be followed by accusative, but this is not the case. Please be ready to analize rather than memorize in Russian, it will help a lot and you will still go mad. Been there myself. Good luck
0
It is the Genitive case. Questions are "возьмите c кого? с ЧЕГО?". Ask also the question "Нету кого/чего?". Check cases here - https://bezbukv.ru/inflect/%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BB . Accusative case question - "возьмите с кого? с ЧТО?" - this is not right, we cannot say "возьми сo ЧТО?" , we say "возьмите с ЧЕГО" ( so, Genitive case)
0
If u talkin about one word - стол, it is Accusative case - столА. "Со " means "from" table

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today