어렸을 때를 생각했어요/어렸을 때가 생각 났어요
책을 보니까 어렸을 때가 났어요
Why is it wrong to say 어렸을 때를 생각했어요? Are there any circumnstances allowing the use 어렸을 때를 생각했어요? Is it flat out wrong?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 3
0
It's quite tricky to explain it. In my opionion, semantically, '니까' emphasizes predicative parts(verbs or 'be adj', NOT objects)
Thinking childhood is not an inevitable result from 'reading', but it can result from the contents or pictures in the book
So, '책을 보니까 어렸을 때를 생각했어요' sounds 'BECAUSE of the 'action' that I 'read' the book, I thought my childhood'
'책을 보니까 울었어요' sounds 'Because of the action that I read the book, I cried'. Not because of 'the book'
It's okay to say '배가 고프니까 밥을 먹는다'(Because of the fact that I 'am hungry', I eat)
'책을 보니까 졸리다' (Because of the 'action' of reading the book, I feel sleepy)
'책을 보니까 엄마가 나를 칭찬한다' (Because of the 'action' that I read the book, mom pays me a compliment)
(I'm afraid of making you even more confused...)
Anyway, it is okay to say '책을 보고 어렸을 때를 생각했어요'. (I read the book, and I thought my childhood)
0
Well... if you just say 어렸을 때를 생각 했어요
It is correct.
But if you say that something makes you recall or come up with something
Then we say 생각이 났어요.
It sounds like you didn't intend to recall it but you did cuz of something.
For the same reason, you can also say 떠올랐어요
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
