Past Perfect vs. Past Simple (Examples)
Hello there! Could anyone explain WHY?)) I'm reading some examples regarding Past Simple and Past Perfect tenses but I don't get why I can't use these sentences according to another tenses. The examples:
1) I was upset. I HAD FORGOTTEN my bag in the car (Why Past Perfect? Can't I use Past Simple or Present Perfect?
2) I’m very happy working as a lawyer, but I HAD WANTED to be a rock star when I was younger. (Why not just "wanted"?)
3) Leonardo Da Vinci PAINTED the Mona Lisa (Can I use Present Perfect instead of Past Simple?)
4) Had you been in Africa? (As I've read somewhere I need to put the sentence in Past Perfect if that person already has the experience to be in that place. However I've some suspicions that it must be written in Present Perfect and it doesn't matter about their experience.)
Thank you for your time reading it and your help!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
2
I agree, the difference between simple and perfect tenses can be rather tricky...
1) I was upset. I HAD FORGOTTEN my bag in the car.
It's "had" because what occurred was:
a. You forgot your bag in the car.
b. You SUBSEQUENTLY became upset.
It's because the forgetting of the bag happened before the getting upset. If you used the simple past, it would sound as if the two things had happened around the same time - or even, because of the order of the sentence, as if you were upset before you forgot the bag.
2) I’m very happy working as a lawyer, but I HAD WANTED to be a rock star when I was younger.
Well, as far as I'm concerned, this one could indeed be "wanted" - because it says "when I was younger", which makes the time clear. Still, "had" is strictly speaking more correct because of the order of events as described in (1) above.
3) Leonardo Da Vinci PAINTED the Mona Lisa.
You can't use "has painted", I'm afraid. One function of the present perfect is to draw attention to the impact of this event on the present situation, and that's not the case here. (Eg. "now that Leonardo has painted the Mona Lisa, I can go to sleep" - which doesn't make much sense.)
4) Had you been to Africa?
This sentence could only be used in very specific cases, again according to the time rule in sentence (1), and probably needs a time modifier such as "before" or "previously". If you were talking about a particular time, and wanted to say "were you ever in Africa before that time?" then you could use this sentence. Eg.
A: My daughter got married in Kenya last year.
B: Oh really? Why?
A: Well, we used to live there when we were younger. We came to England before my daughter was born though.
B: Had she ever been to Africa previously?
If you're just saying this sentence on its own, you're right, you would say "Have you been to Africa?"
0
I am miss Rainna i like to have communication with you , So kindly keep in touch with me right here < [email protected] > to enable us to know better , I will send you my Detail . also i have special something to discuss with you, hope to see your mail soon.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
