Search from various English teachers...
Italy flagSarah
can anyone help me? Lindsay was making a mistake many of us make when faced with the task of redefining ourselves in the face of grief. She was looking to her actions to define who she was rather than deciding who she wanted to be and figuring out which actions supported that self-definition. What does "She was looking to her actions to define who she was rather than deciding who she wanted to be and figuring out which actions supported that self-definition" mean?

Answers · 3

1
The author is playing around the assumption that our actions are a reflection of who we are. If you know who you are, you act accordingly. For example if being religious is part of my identity, with my actions I will support that belief. The author suggests that this is the best way to go about. But Linda is griefing so she's not clear minded, she is likely emotionally broken and doesn't know what to do with herself. So she tries things, she does actions hoping that she will find her new self again, because due to her loss, she doesn't know who she is anymore.
0
Dear Sarah, She was looking to her actions to define who she was rather than deciding who she wanted to be. Defining who she was is more Lindsay understanding what kind of a person she was at that moment. Deciding who she wanted to be is about what kind of a person she aspired to become in the future. In other words, one is about her present, and the other about her future. by 'figuring out which actions supported that self-definition', Lindsay wanted to justify those two definitions. What she had done until that point that helped her come up with those definitions. For example, if until then she had made lots of friends, she could've concluded she was sociable and friendly. Hope these help. Good luck!
0
The passage is quite literary, so there may be multiple interpretations. However, this is one way of understanding what it means: First, let's understand what it means to "self-define". Self-defining means "to give yourself an identity". For example, I can define myself as an "adventurer". That self-definition or identity is supposed to capture my outlook on life, or how I live my life. That comprises my identity. Now, imagine a list of things you have done: {A, B, C, D, E}. A is an action, B is some other action, C is another action, etc. For example, A = "I watched a movie", B = "I climbed a mountain", C = "I traveled alone across the world", D = "I cooked a meal for my family", and so on. METHOD #1: You can look at {A, B, C, D, E} and say "What kind of person does {A, B, C, D, E}? I did {A, B, C, D, E}; therefore, I am the kind of person who does {A, B, C, D, E}." In this case, you are taking the set of actions you have done, and then finding which identity or definition matches those actions. In other words, you look at {A, B, C, D, E} and ask yourself "What kind of person would do {A, B, C, D, E}? That is who I am." For example, you might say "The kind of person who does {A, B, C, D, E} is a 'philosopher'. So, I am a philosopher. 'Philosopher' is my identity." METHOD #2: Imagine you say "I will come up with my own definition/identity/character! I want to be an 'adventurer'. 'Adventurer' is the identity or definition I want to have." Now, you look at {A, B, C, D, E}, and you ask yourself: "Which actions from {A, B, C, D, E} are what an adventurer would do?" For example, B ("I climbed a mountain") is something an adventurer would do. So, you tell yourself "Yes, I am an 'adventurer' because I have climbed a mountain, and that's what adventurers do!" The sentence says: Most people do #1. However, #1 is a mistake. Instead, we should do #2. In #2, YOU CHOOSE your own definition/identity. In #1, your identity is just a result that you do NOT CHOOSE directly.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today