Search from various English teachers...
Iran flagAli
Can any one explain the parts marked with '+'? The concept of the speech community is also somewhat abstract because the particular norms that a community uses may or may not be exclusively linguistic in nature, and along with norms about particular linguistic variables and their social meanings and values, +these norms involve evaluations of ways that language is used as well+. One example of how discourse patterns maybe significant within a speech community is found in Hymes(2004). +He presents analyses of narratives from various native American groups, showing how, even when they are produced in English, there are distinctive features which can be traced back to narrative structures in the Native American languages. in other words, such speakers use English in special ways to maintain their separate identities within the dominant English-speaking community+. Are these two paragraphs trying to convey the same thing? I am confused, I think it tries to say that particular ways of speaking can lead to form certain ideologies. I mean , every speech community has some ideas for themselves, exclusively in terms of how to speak that language. They evaluate and mark other speakers based on their norms if they are not follow them. But I can't understand the next paragraph. Does it want to say the same thing? That every speech community wants to demarcate themselves by special ways of speaking that language?

Answers · 8

1
hi I think what this paragraph is trying to say is that even though people are using the same language, they tend to keep their own identity . It kind of reminds me the story of Pygmalion by George Bernard Shaw which is the story of a poor flower girl is trained by a linguist to speak properly. In one part of the story the flower girl is speaking like a duchess, using proper language, but conveying a poor flower girl's thoughts and feelings... I think in the second paragraph the same the same thing is happening to native American they use language but their are distinctive features that separates their identity within the English speaking community... Good luck!
0
Yes, it does. He says that the idea of speech community is somehow abstract because there are some norms used by speakers that may be non-linguistic and one good exemple is that of the Native American narratives, which even translated in English, mantain some characteristics of the Native American language. This differentiate that English of those narratives to that spoken and written by most English people fron the US. This is what I understood, but I feel that in order to understand it completely, I should be able to read the whole theory.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today