Search from various English teachers...
Iran flagFarhad
does this sentence make sense? Although we all seem to be peculiarly inept at predicting the likely development of our technologies, we can try to extrapolate from the experience of previous technologies, nevertheless, how justified one might be in doing so remains an open question.

Answers · 6

0
Thank you, dear John
0
Yes it makes sense especially much more so when we have the full context. This is a common problem with peoples notebooks they don't provide the full context or a link. This often causes bad corrections, from everybody.
0
Hi Jim here's the whole paragraph: As far as prediction is concerned, remember that the chairman of IBM predicted in the fifties that the world would need a maximum of around half a dozen computers, that the British Department for Education seemed to think in the eighties that we would all need to be able to code in BASIC and that in the nineties Microsoft failed to foresee the rapid growth of the Internet. Who could have predicted that one major effect of the automobile would be to bankrupt small shops across the nation? Could the early developers of the telephone have foreseen its development as a medium for person-to-person communication, rather than as a form of broadcasting medium? We all, including the ‘experts’ seem to be peculiarly inept at predicting the likely development of our technologies, even as far as the next year. We can, of course, try to extrapolate from experience of previous technologies, as I do below by comparing the technology of the Internet with the development of other information and communication technologies and by examining the earlier development of radio and print. But how justified I might be in doing so remains an open question. You might conceivably find the history of the British and French videotex systems, Prestel and Minitel, instructive. However, I am not entirely convinced that they are very relevant, nor do I know where you can find information about them on-line, so, rather than take up space here, I’ve briefly described them in a separate article. is the sentence considered as the summerize of this paragraph?
0
Yes and maybe no. Perhaps more context of the rest of the document would help.I tried to read it with a critical eye and offer the following (I could be way off base!) I think the sentence structure is fine, but I don't understand the message. Starting at "Although..." this is stating 1) we can't predict future technology very well. Then "We ..." is stating 2) we can use history to predict the future but "How..." is where I get confused and I'm not sure what the open question is. One possible interpretation as written is "there instances where the is not justification to try to extrapolate from history" another interpretation is "perhaps we should not try to make technological predictions".
0
Thank you, Pasargadae (: But it's not mine! I just summarized a paragraph from an English book.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today