What's the difference between would and did?
"Four months, two weeks, and five days into the mission, we received Nephthy's final message. (Nephthy = A space colony ship) Panicked voices broken by static. An alien message impossible to decipher. Then nothing. Our first generation of warships ***would*** lead the rescue operation. When we arrived, we soon located the remains of Nephthys floating in the darkness."
Could anyone be nice and find an exact entry from any dictionary for the usage of that would in the paragraph? Because I saw a post on the other site a few years ago that OP asked the same question as in my title. But all the comments of that post said that the usage of would was past habitual actions. But OP kept asking that over and over that, to him, it did not seem to be the case, and to me, a non-native, I felt the same way. But he didn't get any good answer. Here, I'm asking the same again. In many dictionaries, the usages of would that are related past tense are usually these three types: (1) past habit, (2) past volition, (3) past prediction. But, if you see my example, (3) can't be right because they actually sent the rescue team. (2) didn't feel right either because, I don't know but, the tone of voice(?) doesn't seem to fit with the situation. They are just saying the fact that they sent them, not the attitude of them, right? Lastly, (1) shouldn't be the case either because they didn't dispatch rescuers over and over. They did once. The problem is that I got nothing left to match. Please help. Just what is the difference between these below?
"Our first generation of warships would lead the rescue operation."
"Our first generation of warships led the rescue operation."
If you put a link for the entry of any dictionary with your explanation, then it would be the most grateful.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 5
1
"would" has many uses. In your example, it is an example of the "future-in-the-past."
Simple example:
(a)
In May, the young man joined the army.
[present-in-the-past ; present time = May]
In September, the young man died in combat.
[present-in-the-past ; present time = September]
(b)
In May, the young man joined the army.
[present-in-the-past ; present time = May]
In September, the young man would die in combat.
[future-in-the-past ; present time = May]
More information:
https://www.thoughtco.com/future-in-the-past-grammar-1690811
1
I don't see why you dismiss past prediction as thats what i would call it. The author is writing about the decision being made at a particular moment in the past that at a point in the future the warships will lead so it is a prediction/decision made in the past which is being referred to at a later date
If the author used led they would be referring to the simple action rather than the decision and would therefore be less revealing of the process.
I hope this helps
0
Our first generation of warships led the rescue operation
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
