Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagMax
Can I use Past Continuous? In my Gramma book there is a task showed below: "Put the verbs in brackets into the correct form" There is a sentence: Bob_________(take) a nap while I_______(paint) the ceiling. My version is: Bob was taking a nap while I was painting the ceiling. But in the keys to this task sentence forms like below: "Bob took a nap while I was painting the ceiling." May my version, mentioned above, be valid? My thoughts are directed as following: Bob was performing/doing his action (sleep) during some event (when I was painting the ceiling). So, we have a temporary action taking place at a given moment in the past, and it fairly to use Past Continuous in both clauses of considered sentence. Am I right?

Answers · 10

1
"Bob was taking a nap while I was painting the ceiling" is a correct sentence in so far as it contains no grammar errors. However, it's an incorrect solution to the question. The problem is that we would be very unlikely to say this in the real world. This is because we use the past continuous to give background information about what was going on at the time when a significant action or event occurred. That's why the usual textbook example is something like, "We were having breakfast when the earthquake struck". The past continuous serves only as support: it is used to provide CONTEXT for the main action of the sentence. The main action ( i.e. what happened) is usually in the past simple, while the past continuous just gives us extra contextual information. So, if you have a sentence with two verbs in the past continuous and no verb in a simple tense, you are not giving any meaningful information. It's all context and no information! For the sentence to be meaningful, at least one of the verbs would need to be in the past simple. For example: "What did Bob do while you were painting the ceiling?" "Bob took a nap while I was painting the ceiling." In this scenario, we'd assume Bob knew that I'd be painting the ceiling for an hour or so and he realised that this was a good opportunity for him to take a nap. The action = Bob's nap: The context = my painting the ceiling What did you do while Bob was sleeping? "I painted the ceiling while Bob was sleeping." In this scenario, perhaps I knew that Bob would be asleep for an hour or so and I realised this was a good opportunity for me to paint the ceiling. This is what parents of young children often do. The action: my painting the ceiling: The context = Bob's nap Note that you could also put both verbs into the past simple. If you say "Bob took a nap while I painted the ceiling", this would mean that both actions were equally significant and that they happened simultaneously. I hope that makes sense.
0
Yes, your version is correct as well. Using past continuous twice is correct when you are providing a background description on what was happening. "Bob was taking a nap while I was painting the ceiling". You are providing background information to someone, saying 2 events were simultaneously happening - Bob napping and you painting. The version given in your grammar book is correct too, but by using a mix of past and past continuous the meaning is slightly different to yours. Rather than proving a background description saying how 2 events were happening at the same time - painting, napping - it is more saying an event (took a nap) occurred DURING another event (painting). So both yours and the grammar book's versions are correct. You provide a background description where Bob was sleeping AND you were painting. The grammar book takes a different approach and focuses on an event - Bob taking a nap - that took place DURING this other event, painting.
0
Hi Max, Both the options are correct. However, when we use these two tenses together, it shows us that the past simple action happened in the middle of the past continuous action, while it was in progress. Example. While I was studying, I suddenly felt sleepy. - We often use these tenses to show an action interrupting another action. 1. I broke my leg when I was skiing. 2. As I was going to work, I saw an old friend. In the case of this particular sentence, it shows that the past simple action (Bob took a nap), happened in the middle of the past continuous tense (While I was painting the ceiling.) Hope this helps. Thank you, Himani
0
Key is the word “while”. What were you guys doing at 2pm? Bob was taking a nap and I was painting the ceiling.
0
Assume there are two different sentences. At 9 pm, Bob was taking a nap and continued napping till 10 pm. At 9 pm, I was painting the ceiling and I continued painting till 10 pm. So, both the actions were taking place at the same time. Thus, your sentence, 'Bob was taking a nap while I was painting' is correct. I chose a simple way of explaining without using many grammatical terms.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today