Why is this an object in the sentence below?
I saw this sentence in the book "Communicate What You Mean" :" This typewriter is for the secretary but not for the students"
The book says " for the secretary and for the students are objects" but why? Is the verb "be" transitive here?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 2
2
There is no *direct* object. The entire phrase, “for the secretary but not for the students” is the predicate. “The secretary” and “the students” are objects of the preposition “for”.
Other than a prepositional object, “to be” can also take a predicate nominative. Let’s take a look at another sentence: “They are the people.” Once again, there is no direct object. “The people” is a predicate nominative. We could just theoretically say “The people are they.” Here’s another example, illustrating the use of nominative pronouns in the predicate: “I am he” and “He is I.” Note that in spoken English, you’ll usually hear the object pronouns in the predicate, even thought the nominative (subject) pronouns are officially correct: “I’m him” and “He’s me”.
Let me know if this answered your question.
0
Verbs can sometimes be both intransitive and transitive and in this example I would say that it is intransitive as the verb 'to be' is not being done by anything. It is followed by a preposition 'for' rather than a direct object which would make it transitive.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
