Search from various English teachers...
South Korea flagHyuk
'For' or 'to' someone? (when introducing someone's opinion or argument) Hi, As far as I know, "to" is the right choice for introducing someone's argument. But what about my second example below? It sounds better (to me) when I use "for" instead, and Google search suggests there are many similar sentences starting with "For". Could anyone clarify this? 1) To him, characterizing civil society merely as a ‘realm of solidarity’ (Alexander, 1997; Amoore & Langley, 2004, p. 92) in which collective actors are coherently oriented toward ‘progressive transformation’ omits a key part of the contemporary transnational activism, that is, the “rival activism,” and thus, loses sight of the larger political dynamics of global issues (Bob, 2012). 2) For social constructivists, reality is shaped by human knowledge which has been “historically produced and culturally bound,” and in turn, this socially shared knowledge—which comprised of symbols, rules, concepts, and categories—shapes how individuals construct and give meanings to reality (Barnett, 2014, p. 158).

Answers · 6

2
They are both correct, but subtly different. When you say "to me" or "to them" you are emphasizing the person or group, in this case "me" or "them". When you say "for me" or "for them" you are emphasizing the following clause. Something affects them and you're emphasizing that something. Take these sentences as an example: "This book is important to me." "This book is important for me." In the first sentence, I'm emphasizing "me". I am the reason the book is important, perhaps because it's sentimental to me. In the second sentence, I'm emphasizing the book. The book holds importance, because I need it or the information inside of it for something.
2
Good question. I agree that “for” sounds better in the second example. However, I can’t think of a clear rule to govern the situation. In many examples I can think of, both “for” and “to” sound OK. But here is one possibility: “for” may be better when discussing an argument or idea that the person holds or likes, and “to” may be better when discussing an argument or idea that the person does not hold or dislikes. Examples: “To most liberals, the proposal for a flat tax is objectionable because it disproportionately burdens lower income people.” Compare: “For liberals, combating global warming is a high priority.”

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today