Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagMakoto Onhr
Tense question The world's tropical forest are disappearing at a faster rate than experts had thought.

The last part "had thought" can be written "thought" instead, right?

But strictly speaking , the nuances between the two are defferent from each other? Or is there a clear reason that should be "had thought"?

At first, I thought that because the main sentence have present tense "are", "had thought" is not correct. Past perfect tense can be used only if the same sentense has past tense. It is correct, isn't it?

Please help me with that!

Thank you in advance.

Answers · 6

3
I believe the reason why past perfect is used here is because it is implied that experts have (already) changed their minds. They now know how quickly the forests are really disappearing. So the real meaning is "tropical forests are (currently) disappearing at a faster rate than experts had thought [before they realized how quickly the forests are actually disappearing]." The implication is that the experts themselves have already realized that they were wrong. You could say "than experts thought," but usually you would add a little bit more to the sentence in that case: "than experts previously thought," or "than experts thought in the past," or "than experts thought ten years ago." I'm not really sure why it seems necessary to do this, but if you just say "than experts thought," it sounds more abrupt (as though the new information was very recent), and a bit more colloquial. Here's an example that might help. If I meet John for the first time today, and I'm surprised by how tall he is, I might say to him, "You're taller than I thought." But if I met John yesterday, then today I could say to someone else, "I met John yesterday. He's taller than I had thought." I'm using the present tense ("is"), because he is still tall today. But I'm saying that he is taller than I "had thought" before I met him. I could also say "He is taller than I thought," and this would be fine too. But saying "had thought" gives a more complete picture of the sequence of events.
0
こんにちは。たまたま同じ質問してました。よければわたしの質問についた回答もみてください。
0
Thank you for the suggestion. Actually, I uploaded my question with my phone. And I read in laptop, then realized what you meant. I don't know what happens but I'll pay attention about that because this is annoying to read.
0
If you use 'had thought' here it means the scientists had thought it before, but don't anymore. Using 'thought' instead in this context would be better yes. The past perfect is usually used when the rest of the sentence is in the past tense as you've stated.
0
Just a suggestion: You should try to copy/paste using plain text, not html. This will avoid all the html code (for example.

) in your entries. .

The last part "had thought" can be written "thought" instead, right?

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today