Are these two sentences same meaning?
I know a girl who was named Mary.
I know a girl whose name is Mary.
I am confused about the grammar of tense and attributive clauses.
QAQ懵
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 10
2
Hi Pearl
Both sentences are correct but you may use them differently depending on the situation
I know a girl who was named Mary
This sentence tells us that you presently know a person who was named Mary in the past.
I know a girl whose name is Mary.
This sentence tells us that you presently know a girl who possesses the name Mary (that is the name she owns).
1
To begin let's define who and whose. Who is the singular pronoun that takes the place of she/he/they. Whose is possessive form of who.
To say, "I know a girl who was named Mary." You inform the reader that you know a person who is named Mary.
To say, "I know a girl whose name is Mary." You inform the reader you know a girl who owns/possessives the name of Mary.
You may say both sentences as both are correct when speaking. Overall, the idea of using 'whose' is to show possession.
1
Technically, "I know a girl who was named Mary" means that you presently know a girl who was named Mary at some point in the past. It implies she might not be named Mary now. A better way is to say "I knew a girl who was named Mary." That means you used to know a girl whose name was Mary when you knew her. It implies you no longer know her.
Examples: You are introduced to someone who tells you her name is Mary. You might respond, "I know a girl who was named Mary, but she goes by Katherine now." In the second version, you might say," I knew a girl who was named Mary. We went to elementary school together years ago."
"I know a girl whose name is Mary" is the same thing as "I know a girl who is named Mary," which is the grammar structure you used in your first sentence. Both of whose mean that you currently know a girl whose name is Mary now.
In all of those examples, "whose" is used to say the name belongs to or is attributed to Mary.
0
I know of a girl named Mary.
I know of a girl whose name is Mary.
Not sure what the terms mean, but it is "named" or "whose name is", "named" in an adjective, "whose name" - clause.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
