Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagMaks
Present perfect double meaning Hi, there. I'm confused with double way of using a present perfect tense. As I know we should use present perfect tense in two cases: 1. When we are talking about something that started sometimes ago and still exist (ex. We have married two years ago. It's mean that we are still married) 2. When we are talking about experience (ex. I have visited the USA two times) And my question is about a sentence: "I have worked with people". How a English native speaker will consider this sentence? That I started to work with people and still working or that I have an experience to work with them?

Answers · 8

5
To be honest, it is an odd sentence, just like that. If I heard someone say that, I would think "Of course, hasn't everyone?". It makes more sense if you qualify it: "I have worked with Russian people", "I have worked with disabled people". That means that you have experience working with these people, because you have worked with them previously.
3
The first meaning only works when you give a time period. This often involves 'since' or 'for' . For example, "We've been married for two years" means that you got married in 2017 and you're still married now. [Note the correction to your example. The word 'married' is an adjective here, so you need to include the past participle 'been'. Similar example are "I've been sad since you left me" or "I've been ill for three weeks".] If you don't include the time period, a present perfect either indicates a recent event with an impact on the present (as in "I've lost my phone") or a fact about your life in general (such as "I've never been to Australia") For example, if someone says 'I've been married', we'd assume that they are single now, but they were married at some point in the past and then they got divorced. If it stands alone, the statement "I have worked with people" refers to an aspect of the speaker's experience. If it has a time period, such as "I have worked with people all my life" or "I have worked with people for the last ten years", we know that it is an ongoing situation.
3
Most people would understand this sentence as something that has already happened in the distant past. So If you want your sentence to mean that you started to work and is still working with them, then it's better to use present perfect continous tense "I have been working with..." Also note that your sentence "I have worked with people" is not complete... I don't see it being a practical sentence to use in a normal conversation. Better add an adverb like "I have worked with people before".
2
lt comes across that you have had experience with working with people before, but not presently.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today