Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagkakaka
the seats/seats ※I just made them up.they are not some sentenses I found on internet. ❶the seats in the train are dirty. ❷seats in the train are dirty. How differently do you understand them? This is my understanding about them.Do I understand them correct? ❶=some specific set of seats in a specific train are dirty. ❷= a specific train usually has (many) dirty seats/generally seats in a specific train are dirty.

Answers · 7

0
The seats on the train are dirty. (present/future). The seats on trains are dirty (general). The seats on the train were dirty (past). I would never say 'in' the train.
0
Seats on the train could make sense if you had been talking about a train before.. e.g. There are disadvantages to taking both the bus and the train. Seats on the train are dirty, while the bus is slow. But again, this is tricky because 'the train' here means 'trains in general', not a specific train. It's quite difficult to explain, sorry!!
0
Seats on the train are dirty doesn't make sense.. because the statement is half specific and half general. 'seats' - general 'the train' - specific so it needs to be either general - 'seats (in general) on trains (general) are dirty or specific - the seats (the specific seats) on the train(s) (a specific train or trains) are dirty.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today