The photos or photos/the article
I came across these sentences in BBC to wonder if "the photos" or "photos" is right at that position.
I have posted the same kind of question here on italki and learned that they would mean just the same.
So ,again, this time "People have thought the photos I took in the ‘chapels’ were actually modern artwork." and "People have thought photos I took in the ‘chapels’ were actually modern artwork." mean just same.
Or is there any slight difference?
( I just guess that the first one sounds like the speaker is talking about all the photos that he took and the second one sounds like he is talking about some photos that he took.this would be something I just feel, which means I've understood it wrong for a while.)
************
People have thought the photos I took in the ‘chapels’ were actually modern artwork. When I told them that these were marble caves, they were astounded!” said Chelsea Dietsche, an American visitor based in Chile.
************
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 10
0
"the photos" refers to a specific set or collection of photos. "the" is expressing that these are specific, certain photos that the person is discussing. The set he's discussing is probably the photos he's taken in chapels, but it doesn't explicitly say that, it's implied.
"people have thought photos I took in chapels..." This context refers to any photos he has taken in chapels.
So, in this context, the sentences mean basically the same thing, but in certain contexts it could definitely alter the meaning. For example, if I asked you, "Could you please get me THE flowers from the garden?" I would be referring to a specific bunch of flowers that should be understood,. However, if I asked, "could you please get me flowers from the garden?" this would refer to ANY of the flowers in the garden, and not THE specific flowers I'm asking for.
I hope this helps :)
0
Or it depends on how specific speaker think a noun?I mean this time the speaker think it specific enough to use "the", meaning if another person express the same
meaning, he wouldn't use "the" there: just "photos"?
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
