question
Could you help me correct the stuff I wrote?
On New Year's Eve, we went to the Town Hall, where ( were ) gathered a lot of people. Twenty minutes later, the Town Hall clock would strike twelve. But, at five to twelve, it stopped. Seems like it refused to welcome the New Year. Then the crowd began to laugh and sing after getting / learning it was an accident. What a bizarre Eve / evening!
Question: What’s the difference between ‘On New Year's Eve, we went to the Town Hall, where gathered a lot of people’ and ‘On New Year's Eve, we went to the Town Hall, where WERE gathered a lot of people?’
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
2
On New Year's Eve, we went to the Town Hall, where a lot of people were gathered. In twenty minutes, the Town Hall clock would strike twelve but, at five to twelve, it stopped, seeming as if it refused to welcome the New Year. On learning that it was an accident, the crowd began to laugh and sing. What a bizarre evening!
You would use "Twenty minutes later" to begin describing what happened twenty minutes later; here you are describing what was expected, not what happened.
"Seems like it refused to welcome the New Year." is typical of speech, but not writing: it has no subject ("it seems") and 'like' should not be used with a verb, only a noun.
'getting' doesn't fit hear, you could use 'getting to know', but 'finding out' would be better.
On learning.. the word order needed to be reversed - the learning came first, then they laughed afterwards.
'Eve' is only used in special contexts, such as the name of a festival. You would use it if you wrote in full 'what a bizarre New Year's Eve'
Re. your question:
- a lot of people gathered: focus is on the action of gathering.
- a lot of people were gathered: focus is on the outcome of gathering, i.e. the fact that many people were already there.
0
If you post your text in the notebook forum, correctors have better tools (colours, strike though, ...).
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
