Search from various English teachers...
China flagYi Zhang
Is there any mistakes in this sentence? I am practicing to spot and fix mistakes in wording and grammar. In the following sentence, I believe that the word “professionally” is unnecessary. However, I am not certain about the third clause. Could we use “collectively" like this? Please let me know if there are other mistakes that I failed to spot. Having “professionally” trained in landscape architecture and urban design, he has gained in-depth knowledge of design, research, and a history of each domain, and "collectively" on the relationship between urban landscape and contemporary urbanism.

Answers · 10

1
Hello, You are right with "professionally" - it is unnecessary in the first sentence. In the second sentence you could remove "collectively on" as that term is unnecessary. Does that answer your question? Ross
1
Having trained in landscape architecture and urban design, he has collectively gained in-depth knowledge of design, research, and a history of the relationship between urban landscape and contemporary urbanism.. Your are correct professionally is redundant, the rest of the sentence can work with a little re-working. However the whole sentence is longer than necessary. Having trained in landscape architecture and urban design, he has also gained in-depth knowledge of the history of the relationship between urban landscape and contemporary urbanism..
0
@Ryan Winston Elliott Thank you so much for your comment. I like your advice that split the sentence into two.
0
I would argue that your use of 'professionally' is ok, however, the 'collectively' is where I might make a comment. I think that this is a bit of a run on sentence, you could split this second half into two sentences for sure. My own suggestion would be the following Having professionally trained in landscape architecture and urban design, he has gained in-depth knowledge of design, research, and a history of each domain. In addition, he has collectively understood the relationship between urban landscape and contemporary urbanism. Edit: Then again, looking at others comments, 'professionally' and 'trained' are a bit redundant, so I suppose you could fully omit 'professionally' from the beginning. I would stand by my 2nd comment though on collectively.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today