Search from various English teachers...
Ukraine flagRoman
The unclear parts of a song There are 2 phrases in a song of Lucy Schwartz "You are you are" I don't understand: You are you are Something that haunts You are the holy ghost What means "Something that haunts"? You are you are My only song You are the hymnal lost What means "the hymnal lost"? Help me, please.

Answers · 2

1
To hopefully add to John's interpretation: There is also the fact that 'haunt' is a word that is also used to describe what ghosts do. A 'haunted house' is a house that is reputed to be inhabited by ghosts. Although they are using the phrase 'holy ghost', which is a concept in christian doctrine, people very commonly associate the words 'ghost' and 'haunt'. In terms of 'hymnal lost', they could be saying that without that person, there is no way to sing the song.
1
Songs can be really hard to interpret. Here, “haunts” means “stays in the memory.” It is usually used in a negative sense. Example: “The memories of the war still haunt him.” Here, maybe the singer “lost” this person (e.g., to death, to a break-up in the relationship) and the memory of the person and the feeling of “loss” still cause a sense of pain. A hymnal is a book that contains the words and music for religious songs. Hymnals are used in church when the congregation sings. Maybe, “hymnal lost” means that the person who used to give meaning and beauty to the singer’s life has been lost. “Hymnal lost” = “Lost hymnal”; the adjective “lost” is placed after the noun “hymnal,” which is unusual in normal speech but is used in poetry and, sometimes, songs (either to get the rhythm/meter right, or for an “old-fashioned” effect).

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today