Please correct my sentences
Have you won the award?
Yeah, it's no big deal.
I heard you won an award?
Yeah, it's no big deal.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 5
2
From a grammar perspective, they're both fine as is.
The one sentence, "Have you won the award?" is slightly odd. "Have you..." implies that there is a situation that has been going on for some time, and the person is asking if the situation has ended. For example, "Have you finished cleaning your room?" or "Have you arrived at the office?"
The phrase "Have you won the award?" might be appropriate if the winning of the award is a situation that has been going on for some time. For example, perhaps the person wins an award after selling $5000 and this person has been working towards the award.
But most of the time that an award is won, it is not an ongoing situation. It is a single moment in time. So "Did you win the award?" is more natural in most cases.
(Also, "I heard you won an award" can be a statement or a question, and the meaning is slightly different. "I heard you won an award." means "I received information that states you won an award and I believe it. "I heard you won an award?" means "I received information that states you won an award, but I do not fully believe it and I am seeking confirmation.")
0
thank you
0
Did you win the award? (simple past - used for a completed action which occurred at a known (or assumed) moment in the past)
Have you won the award? (present perfect - used for a completed action which occured during a period ending at the present moment)
Did you go to London last year?
Have you been to London since last year?
North American English uses the simple past for situations in which British English uses the present perfect.
(British) Have you been to London recently?
(North American) Did you go to London recently? or Have you been to London recently?
Have you won the award? (there is only one award under discussion - Have you won it during a period ending at the present moment?)
Did you win the award? (there is only one award under discussion - the date of the contest and award are known to both speakers, so it is regarded as a known moment in time rather than a period of time)
Did you win an award? (there are multiple awards - Did you win one of them?)
I heard you won an award? (other people mentioned to me that you had won one award (of multiple awards) - Is it true?)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
