What is omitted is enhance any directly necessary function. Is it right?
In our society, artistic value has been placed on objects that are seemingly useless. Their purpose has been to enhance, not to serve any directly necessary function. Those that do — useful vessels, architectural plans — take on different and, in the romantic hierarchy of values, lesser meaning. They can be artful but they are not “art.” They intersect too directly with daily existence.
Their purpose has been to enhance, not to serve any directly necessary function.
What is omitted is enhance any directly necessary function. Is it right?
I don't understand what "Their purpose has been to enhance any directly necessary function." means
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
0
You could restate this part as "Their purpose has been to enhance. Their purpose has not been to serve any directly necessary function." The word "enhance" usually has an object after it, but in this case, it stands alone. It is a very ambiguous sentence so I can see your confusion :) hope that helps.
0
In our society, artistic value has been placed on objects that are seemingly useless. Their purpose has been to enhance, not to serve any directly necessary function. Those that do — useful vessels, architectural plans — take on different and, in the romantic hierarchy of values, lesser meaning. They can be artful but they are not “art.” They intersect too directly with daily existence.
-------
'Enhance' in the given sentence does have its object: necessary function. The author seemed to have seen 'art' as a kind of necessary function. Therefore 'enhance' and ' serve' have a common object: necessary function.
However, I don't think this sentence is well structured, as what you think, I suppose, because the two verbs' objects are not actually identical: necessary function VS any directly necessary function. This will thereby cause difficulty for readers to identify their separate objects. Being a careful author, they should have put a comma before 'necessary function'. That will help to make the sentence more readable, although too many pauses then.
Journalists often tend to use awkward long sentences. Long sentences are not definitely bad ones, but to write them is definitely an art.
0
Hi, Corine. May I venture to offer my humble opinion? I think 'enhance' in the given sentence does have its object: necessary function. The author seemed to have seen 'art' as a kind of necessary function. Therefore 'enhance' and ' serve' have a common object: necessary function.
However, I don't think this sentence is not well structured, as what you think, I suppose, because the two verbs' objects are not actually identical: necessary function VS any directly necessary function. This will thereby cause difficulty for readers to identify their separate objects. Being a careful author, they should have put a comma before 'necessary function'. That will help to make the sentence more readable, although too many pauses then.
Journalists often tend to use awkward long sentences. Long sentences are not definitely bad ones, but to writing them is definitely an art.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
