Search from various English teachers...
Ukraine flagAnnaProfessional Teacher
A question to native speakers. How can you reason out the use of "recently" with a past perfect? "He had changed his job recently" (Navigate Intermediate B1+, p.23 Ex.9) Although I've tried to find in various grammar books an explanation for why "recently" should be used here , I couldn't. Any thoughts how I could sort this question out for my students? Thanks.

Answers · 10

3
I'm puzzled about why you're puzzled, Anna. Why do you think that this use of 'recently' is problematic? Did you think it could only be used with the present perfect? 'Recently' in the past perfect has the same meaning as in the present perfect - it refers to the period shortly before the point of reference. In the case of the present perfect, our point of reference is the present moment; in the case of the past perfect, it is a known point in the past. In other words, 'recently' with the present perfect means 'shortly before now', while 'recently' with the past perfect means 'shortly before then'. For example, let's say that Jack applied for a bank loan at the beginning of June 2016. This bank loan was refused because Jack had recently changed jobs. This means that he had left one job and started another one shortly before applying for the loan ( perhaps in April or May of that year).
1
The use of "recently" in this sentence identifies (or describes) the completed action (had changed jobs) as being an activity that had occurred (and was completed) in the recent past. Other time identifiers that could have been used, for example ~ He had changed his job when he moved to a new city. He had changed his job years ago. He had changed his job when he got married. An interesting (to me anyway) idiom though would be the use of jobs, i.e., "He had changed jobs recently," which is how this native English speaker would have said that sentence in the first place.
1
I was puzzled why there should be confusion just because of the word recently. Recently would mean shortly before the time referred to either in the past or the (present tense). Sometimes, you will hear an archaic version of the sentence using the word "held" = he had a job. -> From have. ->it was his job ->now it isn't. And because SU.KI has answered so clearly. Before I had finished my answer. There is no need to put my answer. "held" is more commonly used with a position like a cabinet minister and not a normal 9 to 5 job.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today