Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagNatalia St-Va
When " shall" is used Could you help me please. Sometime ago, I did this online test www.oxfordonlineenglish.com/english-level-test/grammar and made a mistake in the follow sentence: Let's go to the cinema.- Great idea! What film ________ we watch? I wrote " will" why it was supposed to be " shall". This explanation was provided there: We use 'shall' for offers/suggestions when we ask a question. Can you give me more examples and other cases when " shall" is used? Thank you

Answers · 7

5
'Shall' is not used in American English with any frequency at all so if you're studying US English I advise that you forget about it. In British English it is used to make suggestions. It is not possible to use 'will' in that question, 'will' implies a certainty which is not appropriate for a suggestion. Now, myself I (pretty much) never use it and I am of the opinion that it is on the way out with younger people in the UK. This is based on my personal experience and how I perceive that word. Having seen this question pop up on more than one occasion on this site I am aware there are people who disagree with me on that. Personally, in such a context, I would have said 'what film should we watch?' or 'what do you want to watch?'
2
You use shall for the first person (singular and plural) Interrogative form: in suggestions Shall we take the train or a taxi? In requests for orders or instructions ? Shall I lay the table? Shall we lay the table ? What shall I do with these papers? In question tags Let's go out, shall we?
0
Thank you, Jerry , for participating and a given example. Always happy to get your answers:)
0
What Paul has said is interesting. When Gen MacArthur left Corregidor he later stated "I shall return" The point is that in the very few instances in which it is used in AE, it can indicate a promise, not a suggestion. In other words, the General was making a promise to return to the PI. But no, it's not normal to hear in the US. It's still regarded as old-fashioned { years ago it was common here }, British, or comical.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today