About the grammar of a sentence
This is from an article I read online, it's a long sentence:
"These notes were originally prepared for fellow-tutors as a first contribution to a debate, and never intended for wider circulation, but feedback from their first accidental appearance justifies their reappearance, and requests from a number of universities to adapt and re-print them."
I have many questions about the grammar of this sentence.
For instance: "..., and never intended for wider circulation,..." Is it ok to not have the subject in this part? Shouldn't it be like "... ,and it was never intended..."?
The other one is what confused me the most: "... , and requests from a number of universities to adapt and re-print them." I couldn't help feeling that this part of the sentence is not complete. I think it should be more like: "..., and requests from a number of universities to adapt and re-print them were sent to me."
Can anyone help explain this to me? Thanks!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 5
1
In English, as in most languages, repetitive parts can be omitted if doing so doesn't reduce the clarity.
For example, the parenthesized part of these sentences are usually omitted, as they read better without them.
- I am an engineer, and (I) work for the XYZ company.
- I had breakfast at 8:30 and (I had) lunch at 12:00.
- Washington D.C. is the capital of the US, and Beijing (is the capital) of China.
(Note however that there are rules applying to such omissions - we can't just take out any repeated words blindly.)
Your example sentence is doing a similar thing.
It can be broken down as follows ([] shows the subject in each clause, and () the omitted parts)
- [These notes] WERE originally prepared for fellow-tutors as a first contribution to a debate,
--- and (THEY WERE) never intended for wider circulation,
- but [feedback from their first accidental appearance] JUSTIFIES their reappearance,
- and [requests from a number of universities] (JUSTIFY US) to adapt and re-print them.
The sentence is a bit more complicated because of the three top level clauses with distinct subjects and the sub-clause, and also because the last omitted verb is slightly different in form ("justifies" vs "justify us"), but the idea is the same.
Perhaps it would have been clearer if it had been written as two separate sentences.
0
(dup again)
0
the subject for never intended is "notes",
"requests" may need "the" in front of it
the whole paragraph has 3 parts.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
