Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagSuanda
Which one is right?And why? "By 2010, the first six books had been/have been made by Warner Bros".

Answers · 7

2
The answer depends on when you are speaking. If you are speaking in the present (2018) or any time after 2010, you would say: ""By 2010, the first six books had been made by Warner Bros". This is the past perfect verb tense. It means that the books were made in the past before 2010. If you are speaking in the past BEFORE 2010 (e.g. 2009), you would say: ""By 2010, the first six books will have been made by Warner Bros". This is the future perfect verb tense. It means that the books will be made in the future but before 2010. You can't say ""By 2010, the first six books have been made by Warner Bros". "Have been made" is the present perfect verb tense. It means that the books have been made in a period of the time in the past before now (i.e. by now). Even if you're speaking in 2010, you wouldn't say "By 2010." You would say "By now, the first six books..."
1
Hi Natalia. This is a good question. You know, English can be so odd at times, but it's important to remember that there are clear markers for the correct usage, too. So - "by" implies something that has happened and is now a fixed state in the past. For example, if it is now 20:00 pm and it is raining, I could say "by 16:00 it had already started to rain". Now, because "by" is a fixed time in the past, we then have to use the past form of "is", which is, in this case, "had". I hope this helps. Great question.
1
By 2010, first... have been...
0
By 2010, the first six books have been made by Warner Bros. Although 2010 is a time in the past, the past perfect tense is usually used to compare 2 time points. For example: By 2014, the sequel of the movies was made, and the Warner Bros had made the first movie in 2010. At least this is how we were taught in Taiwan XD
0
By 2010, the first six books have been made by Warner Bros. (Because here six books plural)

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today