Search from various English teachers...
China flagChino Alpha
Are the sentences correct? It being a fine day yesterday, he went out for a walk. Being a fine day yesterday, he went out for a walk. A fine day yesterday, he went out for a walk. Having been a fine day yesterday, he went out for a walk. Thank you.

Answers · 7

2
Only the first is correct. It's rather formal, but perfectly correct. The second and fourth are classic errors which many native speakers make. Beginning a sentence with a dependent participle clause only works if the clause refers to the SAME SUBJECT as the main part of the sentence - in this case, 'he'. Sentences 2 and 4 are wrong because 'he' is obviously a human being, not "a fine day". You can say for example, "Having woken early, he went out for a walk", because the "he" of the main part of the sentence is also the person who had woken early. You cannot begin a sentence with a participle clause that has a different subject from the core of the sentence itself. Look up "dangling participle" and you'll find all sorts of examples of nonsense sentences where this rule is broken. Sentence three doesn't work at all.
0
Since it was a fine day yesterday , he went out for a walk.It is transformed into"Been a fine day yesterday, he went out for a walk."The logical subject is HE.The weather cannot be the logical subject , we use past participle instead. Seen from top of the mountain , the city looked spectacular!
0
having been a fine day yesterday he went out for a walk.
0
All but the third seem correct.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today