Please explain the differences among the following sentences..
I'd like to say in advance that I'm very thankful to anyone who answers my question.
If I carry out the plan, everything will be fine.
vs
If I will carry out the plan, everything will be fine.
vs
If I am to carry out the plan, everything will be fine.
If any of the above sentences is grammatically incorrect, please correct it.
(By the way, what I learned from many English grammar books in Korea tells me that "will" usually does not appear in "if" clauses except some cases, which I can't recall. Please help me recall those.)
Thank you again.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 3
3
The most natural is the first: If I carry out the plan, everything will be fine. There is a book named Ëlements of Style"written by a Harvard english teacher...simple, less words the better. The second works but borders not making sense and the third is Ok...but the second part of that sentence would have to say ....everything should be fine.
2
Firstly, your question should say 'between the' rather than 'among the'.
Your books sound like they are correct, as (b) does sound wrong. To correct it means taking out the 'will', which is the same as (a)!
'If I am to' makes it a hypothetical question. I need to decide whether I am going to try to do it or not. I can't think of an example where following that by 'everything will be fine' really makes sense. Normally you would put some consequence of that action there. Perhaps someone else can think of where it might work?
'If I' means either that I may or may not try, but it could also mean I may or may not succeed. That sentence works well.
1
Hi!
They all mean the same thing.
BUT...
I would not use:
"If I will carry out the plan, everything will be fine."
Because the "will" in there just seems weird.
BUT...
Since all have the same meaning, you can just use your 3rd sentence:
"If I am to carry out the plan, everything will be fine."
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
