a GRE verbal section question
Fill the blank with the best answer:
Whales are harmless during their peaceful migrations through the earth's seas, yet men, who _____ superior need, savagely hunted them.
A.assumes B.perpetuate C.retains D.assimilates E.manifests
The answer is A, but I think E would be better.
Can anyone please tell me what's wrong with the choice E?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
1
It’s not a good test question in my opinion, because it’s not very clear what “superior need” (I have never heard of “superior need” before) means.
I suppose you can meaningfully talk about “manifesting a need”, but I’m not sure what it means to manifest a “superior need”. “Superior need” here means - as I understand it - that man believes his needs are more important than the needs of the whales (so he feels entitled to kill them). So I think “assumes” is the only word that makes sense in the context.
0
Thanks for the responds! The explanation to the question says that "assume" in the context means "suppose something to be true". The reason why I chose E is that I thought to manifest a quality means to show/display a quality. We can show/display a need with our expressions or actions, and I think that makes sense. BTW this a question from a GRE mock test, therefore it maybe a little bit controversial and I am still confused.
0
This is a worthless question most likely written by a non-native speaker. It has no value.
0
Hmmm, these are indeed large words.
'Assume' - #1 to believe a piece of information without proof. #2 to 'take on' a responsibility.
'Manifest' - to create/to grow/to make by taking action.
Assume fits better because we, as humans, 'take on' a superior need than a whale (or other animal).
We can't really 'make/manifest' a need by taking action. A need is something that is just part of us. For example: we need food. We need water. We need shelter. But how do we 'make/manifest' the desire to want food or water?
This is an extreme example, I think, however - I think it will help prove the point a bit more.
I hope this helps a little?! [emoji]
0
挺难,我怎么觉得该用 assume 而不是 assumes 呢
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
