Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagAriadna
How can we distinguish the cases in which we should put Passato Prossimo or Imperfetto?:)

Answers · 10

2
Hi Adriana, A good start (but not a perfect system) would be to match совершенный вид глагола with passato prossimo, and и несовершенный вид глагола with imperfetto. As I said, this is not a perfect system because then you need to learn trapassato verb forms, as well as passato remoto, plus other differences between Italian and Russian past tenses.
2
L'imperfetto si usa per esprimere un'azione abituale, che si faceva sempre: "Da bambino andavo al mare tutte le domeniche". Un'azione ripetitiva, che si faceva tante volte: "Mia zia faceva sempre dei dolci buonissimi". Un'azione durativa, che è durata per un certo tempo: "Ieri pioveva". Il passato prossimo invece si usa per esprimere un'azione non abituale, che è stata fatta una sola volta: "Da bambino una volta sono andato al mare". Un'azione puntuale, avvenuta una volta: "Mia zia ieri ha fatto dei dolci buonissimi". Un'azione momentanea, breve, che è durata o è avvenuta in un momento: "Ieri è piovuto un po’".
1
Hi, Imperfetto literally means "not concluded" and it is used to report past actions that had a developing in the moment you talk about, or refer to a generic past period where the same action was frequently repeated (habit) --- Mentre andavo a scuola, incontrai te -- While I was going to school, I met you --- Quando ero bambino, andavo a scuola -- When I was a child, I used to go to school You can see that English has different translations for our Imperfect, this might help you see the difference between an Ongoing action (while I was going...), a Period (when I was...) and a Habit (I used to..) Passato Prossimo and Passato Remoto both refer to a concluded action in the Past -- now as a student, just stick on these, because the other compound tenses have a meaning when relating to them: (I quote myself) Our Compound Past -- called Passato Prossimo (eg. "ho studiato") -- is the very same of the Perfect tense -- called Passato Remoto ("studiai") -- but the first one is used when we want "to shorten the distance between us and the Past" (no matter when, even in Prehistory): for example it is used a lot in Travel Guides, so that the Past appears "nearer" -- which is the meaning of "Prossimo" (see: Proxima Centauri). The Perfect instead means "concluded and far away " -- that is "Remoto" (see: Remote control) and it is used in History books. If you want to make a very good practice of verbs, head to Fairy Tales. Search -- grimmstories -- and you'll find translations into your language. For deepening how Verbs relate, see: https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concordanza_dei_tempi

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today