Search from various English teachers...
Allen
A grammatical question, please help. Hello all, I encountered this problem in my textbook. The question is as below: Q: This story shows that it is wrong to tell lies, ______ if you do, you have to suffer. (A)but (B)therefore (C)and that (D)so The answer key says (C), but I think the best answer should be (D). My reason is if the answer is (C), it means "and" is used as a conjunction between two "that" noun clauses, so it doesn't need a comma after the first clause. On the other hand, if the answer is (D), "so" acts as a conjunction between two sentences, which are "this story shows that is tis wrong to tell lies" and "if you do, you have to suffer". Therefore, the comma seems suitable between the two sentences. I was wondering if my understanding is right, so sincerely asking for help here. Thank you.

Answers · 4

1
I think that the reason it is C, is that it is all about 'the story'. The structure is 'The story shows a, and b. I don't think that the 'and' is a joiner of 'that phrases'. If you used 'so', you switch from a report of what the story says, to a general statement in the second phrase. Sorry - I'm not a grammarian, so I'm not that good at analysing structure.
0
Hmm..the correct answer shall be C. As Gary explained, the structure here is that ´the story shows that A and that B.´ Indeed for learners of the English language it´s a common mistake to forget the second ´that´, which is in fact compulsory. D is an incorrect answer. Even if you feel that the meaning fits (although C sounds much more natural), the word ´so´ is NOT a conjunction, but an adverb. You can use a conjunction to connect two complete sentences with a comma--by complete I mean a sentence with one conjugated verb, but (but can functionn as a conjunction, by the way) you CANNOT use an adverb for that function. In other words, the comma must be replaced by a period or a semicolon. This is a rule of punctuation usage in English, which renders it rather distinct from many other langauges, say Chinese or French. Q: This story shows that it is wrong to tell lies./; _So/so_____ if you do, you have to suffer. (A)but (B)therefore (C)and that (D)so The same rule applies to the usage of words like 'moreover, furthermore, additionally, therefore', etc. Hope this helps.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today