Questions about English tense
1.I met a person who [was] from Norway. She [spoke] English fluently.
This "I met a person" event happened in the past, so I use past tense.
But doesn't "was from Norway" imply she is not Norwegian now?
And doesn't "spoke English fluently" imply she doesn't speak English fluently now?
2.When I was a student, I [hated] math.
Does it imply that I don't hate math now?
3.I bring a gift to you. / I brought a gift to you.(Right now I'm going to give you the gift.)
Which one is correct?
4.I [was] so happy that I won the prize. (on the day I knew I won the prize)
But I'm still happy that I won the prize.
Should I use "was" or "am"?
I think these problems are basically based on the same concept in English which I never understand...
I'll be very thankful if you could help me.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
3
1, 2 - This is called Sequence of Tenses. The term "sequence of tenses" refers to the choice of the verb tense in the subordinate clause depending on the tense of the verb in the main clause. The rule of the sequence of tenses means that the tense in the subordinate clause is determined by the tense in the main clause and should agree with it both logically and grammatically. It's just grammar. So the use of past tense doesn't imply, that the person doesn't speak English fluently now or doesn't hate math now.
3. I've brough you a gift. (Present Perfect)
4. Depends on what you want to say: "I was happy that I had won the prize " (if you are telling a story in the past). "I am happy I've won the prize" (if you want to emphasize that you are happy now). Or "I am happy I won the prize that day/2 years ago etc".
I am not a native speaker but that's how I understand it.
0
Hello I'm frum Dixie an' no won speaks Englush like I does. That is very smart commentary on #1 as in, the English speaker would never think of that, it is just taught and not thought. She was from Norway will never mean that she is no longer from Norway. She was from Norway , basically all the "was" past tense indicates is you made this observation previously. It may even be incorrect grammar, She is from Norway serves the same purpose. In fact I think they are both mildly inappropriate grammar. I met a person who is from Norway. She speaks English fluently.
2. There is no hint at all if the student hates math now, but certainly, the student hated math during school. When I was a student, I hated math.
3.I bring a gift to you works. Both these phrases seem excessive,superfluous, formal. I bring good news Sire, tidings from the east, My king, the mongols retreat. I have a gift. Here's a gift from me. I would go with I bring a gift to you.
4.I was so happy that I won the price and I'm still happy that I won the prize.
I don't know besides past tense and present tense, I don't see some major problem at all actually, this is intelligible and respectable English in all circumstances. Particularly, obsession with was/is/will , these are Passive Participles I believe, they just don't strike anyone as important verbs or important problems, I was led to believe, I will be led to believe, I am led to believe.
0
This is called Sequence of Tenses. The term "sequence of tenses" refers to the choice of the verb tense in the subordinate clause depending on the tense of the verb in the main clause. The rule of the sequence of tenses means that the tense in the subordinate clause is determined by the tense in the main clause and should agree with it both logically and grammatically. It's just grammar.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
