Search from various English teachers...
Hungary flaghmano
Present perfect vs present perfect progressive + verbs like live? As I know: Generally , present perfect simple emphasizes the result of the action whereas present perfect progressive emphasizes the duration of the action. Does it mean that indicating the duration I have to use present perfect progressive? I have lived here for 5 years. I have been living here for 5 years. As I know they both can be used and they can mean the same, but the second sentence also means that perhaps that the action lasted only for period of time (temporary duration), and I've moved to somewhere else. Does it depend on the verb used in the sentence? Please help me clarify this.

Answers · 5

2
To answer your actual question. In this situation, they mean the same thing. There is the permanent temporary element. So, I would tend to say "I have lived". A better way of illustrating that would be: I have driven a car for fifteen years (Since I passed my driving test a long year ago) I have been driving for two hours so far (I am in the middle of a journey) We also use it for completion if that helps. If we have completed something but it is still important in our lives, we use the present perfect. If we are still working towards something, we use the continuous; I have been learning to drive for five years (Don't have my license) I have learned to drive (I have my license) My grammar slides may help http://askpaulenglish.blogspot.co.uk/2016/05/present-perfect-continuous-vs-present.html http://askpaulenglish.blogspot.co.uk/2016/08/present-perfect-continuous.html http://askpaulenglish.blogspot.co.uk/2017/01/present-perfect-continuous.html
1
In your example sentences, the meaning is identical and furthermore they both imply that you are still living in the place. However if you were to say something like: 1) I lived there for 5 years. 2) I was living there for awhile. 3) I had been living there for 5 years. 4) I lived here for 5 years. These all imply that you no longer live there. The main differences have to do with past tense verbs like 'lived' or 'had been' and the location words you used 'here' verses 'there' for example. Also, 'had been' instead of 'have been' when speaking in the first person implies the past. 'Have been', on the other hand implies progressive tense. (example: you have been learning English (...and continue to learn English)). Speaking in the third person while using past tense 'had', 'had lived' or 'had been' however can mean that the action 'been' or 'lived' is progressive but not necessarily. Some examples: He had been there for 2 hours. He had lived there/here his whole life. She had lived there for 5 years. I hope I have not confused you more. English is very strange.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today