Search from various English teachers...
China flagDan
Which thesis statement is better reflecting my position? 1. The infamous incident (of a 2-year-old girl being run over by two vehicles but failed to be help by 18 passer-bys) tells everyone a harsh yet straight truth that human nature is bad because people are a selfish animal, which need to be educated to be good, and their kindness is conditional. 2. The tragedy of that 2 year-old girl sheds light on the evil nature of man. Humans are selfish, only under certain conditions they are humane, and they need education for being good. These two may have almost identical meanings, but as a thesis statement, I want to know which one is more specific and convincing. If there are grammar mistakes, please help me correct them. Thanks a lot! If you have any questions on Chinese, feel free to ask for help! :)

Answers · 5

1
Hi Dan, it depends on the question you are answering. The thesis statement should explain exactly how you are going to answer the question/address the topic. The first variant covers two things - that they need to be educated for good and that their kindness is conditional - it is not certain which you are covering in your essay and if it is going to be both. The second one sounds as if your thesis is only about human's needing to be educated for good. Neither thesis indicates that you are going to expound ways that this can be done so if this is your intention, it needs to be in the thesis statement. I hope this helps.
0
Thank you!
0
It would also be better to say: They need education to be good.
0
The second one is more succint and neater. There are a few grammar mistakes here. The infamous incident (of a 2-year-old girl being run over by two vehicles WAS NOT helpED by 18 passerS BY) SHOWS everyone a harsh yet DIRECT truth that human nature is bad ,because people are selfish ANIMALS , which need to be educated to be good, and their kindness is conditional.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today