Search from various English teachers...
China flagAnne
take sth to be/ for sth Are both phrases the same? I have seen both in different sentences. For example, "I took him for your brother." Can I also say " I took him to be your brother" to mean I misunderstood that? If not, what's the difference between the two phrases in meaning? Any answers will be appreciated, thanks!

Answers · 3

1
At first glance, there seems to be no real difference. 1) "I took him for your brother"= "I thought he could be your brother" 2) "I took him to be your brother"= "I thought he is your brother" The difference is really subtle, and I have to qualify, this is based on my gut feel and not based on concrete grammatical rules. For most purposes, it is kinda close to splitting hairs.
1
I would have said the same as Daryl but since reading what he wrote, i would say there could be a difference (also coming from a gut feeling place): 1)"I took him for your brother." = I know you have a brother and i thought that was him. (although i guess you would use the word 'mistook' if that is what you meant) [however, :D 'mistook' may imply that you should have known better, as in you know what his brother looks like but made a mistake; as opposed to simply knowing of his brother but never have met him]. 2)"I took him to be your brother"= "I thought he was your brother" <= same as Daryl However now that i compare it to Daryl's i think he made the same point except in a much simpler way! :D :D PJ

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today