Search from various English teachers...
Morocco flagMustafa
I cant seem to understand this poem! Home is so Sad Philip Larkin, 1922 - 1985 Home is so sad. It stays as it was left, Shaped to the comfort of the last to go As if to win them back. Instead, bereft Of anyone to please, it withers so, Having no heart to put aside the theft And turn again to what it started as, A joyous shot at how things ought to be, Long fallen wide. You can see how it was: Look at the pictures and the cutlery. The music in the piano stool. That vase.

Answers · 10

2
Pt. 2 "Having no heart" is clear enough, but I don't understand "to put away the theft." The second stanza is equally sad, because it asks us to look at the house as a biography, and, the poet says, most biographies are sad. The house carries in it clear signs of early ambitions. Projects that were started but never finished. For years I had a photographic enlarger in our basement because I was planning to set up a darkroom, and never did. I got rid of it. If I'd kept it, it would have a reminder that I'd once wanted to have a darkroom. These trace of ambitious early plans and dreams are "joyous shots at how things ought to be." A literal shot, from a gun or an arrow, has an intended aim. He speaks of shots "long fallen wide." That means they missed, they didn't hit, the dreams failed to come true a long time ago. "You can see how it was." And he then gives us a list of things. These things don't really mean anything to us, because we can't see them. But in real life, in the home of a parent or someone we know well, they all have stories that we know. "The pictures." The picture of someone in a high school play, perhaps, reminding you that the person actually tried to be an actor for a few years before giving up. "That vase." Oh, yes, that was a souvenir of the trip to Belgium, before her arthritis got so bad she couldn't travel. He doesn't mention the enlarger in the basement! Mind you this is all guessing. But the first stanza seems to be talking about how sad a home is when you think of it as marking the end of a life. The second stanza seems to be talking about how sad it is when you think of it as being the record of a life in which the later achievements never really measure up to the earlier dreams. It is possible that the home and the objects in it are all just a metaphor for life itself. But, hey, it's a poem. "A poem should not mean, but be." Other people might get something completely different out of it.
2
Pt. 1 A famous poem by Archibald Macleish ends with the line "A poem should not mean, but be." This poem isn't easy to understand. I don't understand it. No two people would agree on what it means. I can pick out some things here and there. I can't be sure of anything. He appears to be describing a recently abandoned home. As someone whose parents are both dead, I think of the times I've had to clean out an apartment after a death. A home contains things that remind us of the entire life of the person who lived in it. "It stays as it was left" is clear. One the person leaves it, nothing in the home moves. It's frozen in time. Sometimes, when somebody has a child who dies, a teenager perhaps, they leave the room untouched, so you see all of the things the child was interested in... baseball gloves, posters of rock musicians, and so forth. It's sad, and a home is sad after "the last to go" leaves it. "Shaped to the comfort of the last to go" is clear, too. If the person likes to watch television, there will be an easy chair near the television set. If the person likes to read books, there will be bookshelves and a good lamp for reading. Everything is the way the person who lived in the home has arranged it; it's shaped to his comfort. "...as if to win them back" is a fanciful idea. The idea is that the house is alive, and keeps everything comfortable because it loves the person who lives in it and wants him to come back. An abandoned house only "stays as it was left" for a while. Then it deteriorates, of course. Things get dusty and dirty. He carries the idea further: he suggests that houses deteriorate because they get depressed. They were trying so hard to stay comfortable so that the occupant would want to return, and when he doesn't, it is "bereft of anyone to please," so they give up and deteriorate. ("Bereft" means that something you need has been taken away; it's commonly used to describe widows or widowers, bereft of their spouse.)
1
Oh my! I got so sad just by reading the poem and meditating on it and trying to "feel" it. It really is a sad poem. Especially when I read the comments which amplified the sadness even more! But don't get me wrong, I love how the commenters explained the poem. So, if I may also explain it in my own words, own context, own feelings. own interpretation? I really don't know Larkin...but I will try to interpret the poem as it relates to my own experiences. I don't want to explain what it means, but what it "is" to me. I see an empty nest, an empty home. Where the sons and daughters, brothers and sisters, who used to live there, have left. Where there used to be children playing around, the whole family gathering together, such noise but such fullness ,too....now it's all empty. So sad.... It was shaped to the comfort of the last to go. Hah! I know that! When someone leaves the house and those who are left just want her or him back? They will make the place as comfortable and as desirable and as delightful as possible the best they know would please the person who just left. They really miss the person who left and would love her or him back. Personal experience! lol! The home is thus described as a very very sad person waiting and waiaitng for the return of her loved one. Waiting endlessly. But since the person being waited for hasn't come back after a ver very long time now... The house slowly withers, dilapidates, pines away...Oh, how sad this is really!!!!
1
Having no heart to put aside the theft and turn it again to what it started as. Means, the house has lost the heart to put aside the depression and spring back to liveliness and newness. It is such a depressed house. It cannot forget the "theft"; the beloved who left is like a property stolen from her. The hous cannot get over what happened, it cannot get over the theft. It cannot turn itself to what it once was. To its former joys and glory. To its former enthusiasm and joyous goals.Instead, it looks at all those which could have been, what should be. It's still waiting. Looking and waitng. Doesn't care about the deterioration it's now going through. It is still looking at all the memories, and is still hoping for the return of the beloved one.
0
You need a book which explains the background to Larkin's poems. I am also English but I couldn't be clear about the meaning of this unless I studied his poetry seriously.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today