Search from various English teachers...
India flagIndranil
Gone vs going I am giving two sentences below.Please get me clear. I am confused. 1. Mrs. Jones went to the New York. 2. Mr. Smith took up her position. This is the context. If I join the two sentences above into two sentences using the participle, then which sentence is meaningful or does both of them carry the same meaning? Sentences with participle are as follows: a) (With) Mrs. Jones going to New york, Mr. Smith took up her position. b) (With) Mrs. Jones gone to New york, Mr. Smith took up her position. source:Participles (Partizipien)

Answers · 3

0
They both look correct to me. They mean slightly different things, though. a) Mrs. Jones is in the process of going to New York. She hasn't left yet. b) Mrs. Jones has already left for New York (and probably is in New York now).
0
The first part of both sentences aren't grammatically correct. They should be "Mrs. Jones is going to New York.", "Mrs. Jones has gone to New York." The second half is fine grammatically. Having said that, both sentences aren't natural and lack more logic. Here are different natural ways to say it, each is slightly different in usage: Mrs. Jones is going to New York and Mr. Smith has taken up her position/role. Mrs. Jones has gone to New York and Mr. Smith has taken up her position. Mrs. Jones is going to New York and Mr. Smith is taking up her position. Since Mrs. Jones is going to New York, Mr. Smith will be taking up her position.
0
I believe that the first would be correct, but that the second would be correct if you replaced the word "to" with the word "for."

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today