Search from various English teachers...
South Korea flagSonia
When do you say "a good of a speaker"? Hi guys, I have heard somebody say "a good of a speaker" and it's quite new to me as opposed to saying "a good speaker." I wonder when you use this wording. Any difference from just using "a good speaker"?

Answers · 15

1
I've never heard 'a good of a speaker' as a stand alone expression. I can't even think of a decent phrase that would incorporate it. The ones you suggest are fine.
1
"A good of a speaker" would only be used in a comparison- "he is as good of a speaker as she is". On its own it doesn't make sense
0
One way to use this is; "he is that good of a speaker", "He isn't as good of a speaker as he says he is". This is very uncommon but it is possible, but you can say; "He's not a good of a speaker to do this". It sounds very weird but it exists.
0
I find that the American Heritage Dictionary has a usage note about it: "Often, especially in speech, an 'of' is inserted as well: 'too long of a movie;' 'that big of a deal.' But this construction using 'of' is considered ungrammatical; in our 2012 survey, 74 percent of the Usage Panel found the sentence 'That's too long of a movie for me to sit through' unacceptable. A somewhat smaller number, but still a majority—58 percent—disapproved of 'He wanted to apologize, but I told him it wasn't that big of a deal.'"
0
Don't say it. Understand it, but don't say it. In the United States, it _is_ fairly common to hear people say things like "he's not that good of a speaker," "it's not that good of a cell phone," "He wasn't really all that good of a baseball player." The meaning is exactly the same as "he's not that good a speaker," "it's not that good a cell phone," "He wasn't really all that good a baseball player." I can't really explain the meaning or the grammar of the word "of." It's informal, it's colloquial, it's spoken language. I don't think the the "of" is grammatically correct. It really is common, but it's not "good English." Don't use it. Possibly it's regional and possibly it's connected with an ethnic group in which the "of" would be a normal construction in the group's original language. Maybe people just like the rhythm of the words. It is often spoken rapidly, like suffix to the word: "He's not that gooduva speaker." In either case, with or without the "of," the phrase includes an implied comparison to what is expected. "He's not that good [of] a speaker" could mean "He's not as good a speaker as you'd expect, given his fame." "It's not that good [of] a cell phone" could mean "It's not as good a cell phone as you'd expect, given its price." "He wasn't really all that good [of] a baseball player" could mean "For someone in the Baseball Hall of Fame, he wasn't as good a baseball player as you'd expect." Thus, the meaning is slightly different from "He's not a very good speaker," "It's not a very good cell phone," "He's not that good a baseball player."

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today