Search from various English teachers...
Kuwait flagSmile
Past simple and past perfect? I was studying the past perfect and it says if we talk about things that happened before something else in the past, we use the past perfect. I got everything at first but when I saw the coming example I got confused about it : "At first I thought I had done the right thing but soon I realized I had made a big mistake" Why isn't it : At first I thought I did the right thing?

Answers · 5

2
I would add that past perfect is not an absolute requirement even when you talk about "things that happened before something else in the past". I think it is safe to say that it's used only in those relatively few situations where not using it makes the meaning unclear. As was already mentioned, your example can be stated with simple past only, and there will be little chance anyone would misunderstand what was meant. But consider a case like this. 1. When I arrived at the station, the train already left. 2. When I arrived at the station, the train was already leaving. 3. When I arrived at the station, the train had already left. 4. I arrived at the station, got on the train, and a few minutes later it took off. #1 is not that clear because it can mean it left before you arrived, at about the same time(#2), or maybe even after. By using the past perfect as in #3, you can make it clear that the train left before you arrived. On the other hand, in #4 the events are stated in the sequential order, so past perfect is not necessary at all, even though arriving there clearly happened before getting on the train or the train leaving.
2
This is a good question! It makes sense that you're confused. English is weird! This is the best answer I can give you: "At first I thought I had done the right thing but soon I realized I had made a big mistake" is correct, and it's also past perfect, but it's okay to say "At first I thought I did the right thing" in conversational English. That's because, in conversational English, many people use simple past instead of past perfect. Conversational: "She thought she caught the frog, but it jumped out of her hands!" More literary/grammatically correct: "She thought she had caught the frog, but it jumped out of her hands!"
1
because you had done something first and then thought about it, so "done" happened before "thought"
0
don't worry about it, try to listen a lot, eventually it will make sense!
0
yes i'm confused too i think we can use both

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today