Why he not use "was"?
In this sentence : "He lost it in a car accident as a child"
Why he not use "was"?
"as was a child"
Thank you
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 16
4
"As a child" is similar to writing "when he was a child."
I usually use "as a child" to describe what someone was like when he or she was a child, and not something that happened to them. To me, because "losing it" happened to him in your sentence, I would have written "when he was a child."
3
I agree with the other statements, however it is very common to use "as" to also refer to something you normally possess throughout most of your life, such as a body part, or family member. For example :
"Why does he only have one leg? He lost it in a car accident as a child. What happened to his eye? He lost it in a car accident as a child. Why didn't his mother come to the wedding? He lost her in a car accident as a child."
2
You are right, in my opinion, to improve the sentence with "was" e.g. He lost it in a car accident when he was a child."
In this sentence, "as" means in the capacity of a child e.g. I worked for the school as a teacher. "as" does not express the meaning well in this case, in my opinion.
1
To this native speaker's ear it sounds fine. I can see how it's confusing to a learner though.
0
"He lost it in a car accident when he was a child" is easy to be understand in programmer, in my opinion.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
