Sentence analysis
"He left town a pauper. He returned home a millionaire."
1. How would you parse "town" in that sentence?
2. How would you parse "a pauper"?
In other words, can anyone diagram that first sentence?
Thank you VERY much.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
0
Thank you, EVERYONE, for your great answers. (Yes, Maxim, I'm 79.)
I wish that I could have awarded "Best Answer" to every one of you.
You are all the greatest!
(As Susanne said, "a pauper" refers to the subject "He." In a diagram, however, where would "a pauper" fit?)
0
Diagramming sentences is really not done much anymore in the USA. I'm not very good at it.
He-subject
left town a pauper-predicate
left-main verb
town-direct object of verb
a pauper-predicate nominative that refers back to the subject. (I'm not exactly sure about this one.)
Good luck!
0
My impression is that you may be referring to grammatical analysis ("diagram").
If so, I'd say "town" is the direct object of the verb "left" and "a pauper" is the complement for it.
That is, "a pauper" makes the sentence (more) complete by providing additional meaning, just like "happy" in "I am happy". Maybe there are more technical terms for them, but this is all I know :-)
0
I am not sure that I understand fully how to answer, but I can certainly try.
I guess I could break down 'town' into 'large village', since a town is generally larger than a village, yet smaller than a city.I chose 'village' because this seems to be a sentence used to describe a setting in older times, as 'pauper' also is a word used in older times :). I would break down 'pauper' into 'poor man'. So now we have: "He left the village a poor man, but returned a millionaire".
If this isn't clear or helpful enough, let me know and I'll try to get it better.
0
James, are you really 79?
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
