Search from various English teachers...
Poland flagAndrés
Which version is better/more correct? 1. Unemployed people will increasingly vent their frustration, as is the case with their forebears in the Industrial Revolution. Can we use 'as IS the case with' with a reference to the past? or.. 2. Unemployed people with increasingly vent their frustration, as with their forebears in the Industrial Revolution. (Sounds worse to me, but anyway...) I appreciate your input.

Answers · 9

2
I'd probably say "Unemployed people will increasingly vent their frustration, as their forebears did in the Industrial Revolution". But if you want to do something like your #1, then indeed, "was the case" would be better. I don't care so much for your #2, because there's a parallelism problem with the comparison implied by "as".
1
You are talking about something that occurred in the past, so you would want to match that. "Unemployed people will increasingly vent their frustration, as was the case with their predecessors in the Industrial Revolution." So, you can think of it as.. their predecessors are not currently frustrated! Here's another example: "Unemployed people will increasingly vent their frustration, as IS the case with the unemployed in other countries." This one is talking about something that is present and current. Although, I'm not sure if it's true or not ;-)
0
So there is no problem here with using a Present Tense with a reference to the past?
0
The first one is perfect! Just instead of saying 'forebears', predecessors is a more accurate word to use in my opinion

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today